Drawing boundaries

147-4792_IMGMy family and I have been settling into a new home during the last few months, which is why there have been no posts for some time.  You could say that we have new boundaries which define our space in the city.  Indeed, as part of the process of buying our house we received copies of the entry in the UK Land Registry which defined the extent of the property we were purchasing. On a larger scale, ‘boundaries are lines drawn on a map and fought over by man’; this is a quote that I came across sometime ago but unfortunately I have lost the source.  It implies that the judgments made in drawing national or regional boundaries are fraught with difficulty.

Engineers have to draw boundaries in order to define a system for analysis.  In thermodynamics, which is the study of energy, a system is defined as the part of the universe that is the centre of attention and everything outside of the system is described as the ‘surroundings’.  This approach provides enormous freedom in defining the system for analysis and as a consequence there is some significant skill involved in drawing the boundaries so that an analysis is both viable and useful.  Students learning thermodynamics might say it was ‘fraught with difficulty’.

Drawing appropriate boundaries to define a system allows us to evaluate energy and mass transfers in and out of the system and thus assess the capabilities and efficiency of the system.  The system could be a jet engine, a refrigerator or a biological cell.  Of course, the freedom available in drawing system boundaries is open to abuse because organisations can draw the boundaries to optimise the claimed efficiency of their product, so we need to be careful about accepting such claims.  For instance, fuel efficiency values for electric cars look impressive alongside a conventional petrol or diesel vehicle and thus imply less use of the world’s resources; however, such values rarely take account of the generation of electricity at the power station, which might be oil-fired depending on where you live.  Thus a ‘well-to-wheel’ efficiency would be more appropriate if you are interested in global sustainability, or Euros/kilometre if you are more interested in financial efficiency.

4 thoughts on “Drawing boundaries

  1. Pingback: Is Earth a closed system? Does it matter? | Realize Engineering

  2. Pingback: Revisiting closed systems in nature | Realize Engineering

  3. Pingback: Isolated systems in nature? | Realize Engineering

  4. Pingback: Global citizenship in the context of COP27 | Realize Engineering

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.